Proposition 36: What Actually Changed
Prop 36 took effect in December 2024, undoing part of Prop 47. Theft under $950 can now be a felony, and treatment-mandated felonies exist.
In short
Proposition 36 took effect on December 18, 2024. It allows a felony charge for theft under $950 where the person has two or more prior theft convictions, creates a treatment-mandated felony for certain repeat drug offenses, raises penalties for fentanyl and organized retail theft, and requires courts to warn drug sellers about murder liability.
California voters passed Proposition 47 in 2014, reclassifying a set of drug possession and low-value theft felonies as misdemeanors. Ten years later they passed Proposition 36, which took back part of it.
Proposition 36 was approved on November 5, 2024 with roughly 68% of the vote and took effect on December 18, 2024. A great deal of the guidance online about California theft and drug charges still describes the pre-2025 position.
Theft: the $950 rule now has an exception
Under Proposition 47, theft of property worth $950 or less was a misdemeanor in nearly all cases.
Proposition 36 adds an exception: a person with two or more prior theft convictions can be charged with a felony for theft under $950.
It also increases penalties for organized retail theft where three or more people act together, the “smash-and-grab” provision that drove much of the campaign.
What did not change: the $950 threshold itself, and the shoplifting offense in Penal Code section 459.5, which still covers entering a shop during business hours intending to steal $950 or less.
Drugs: the treatment-mandated felony
The measure creates a new category for certain repeat drug offenses. A person charged with one can be ordered into treatment rather than sentenced to prison. Completing treatment can result in dismissal. Not completing it exposes him to up to three years.
Penalties also rise for some drug offenses, particularly those involving fentanyl.
And courts must now give a formal warning to people convicted of distributing certain drugs: that if someone later dies from a drug they supply, they can be charged with murder. That warning is the foundation of a later implied-malice prosecution, in much the same way the standard DUI advisement supports a Watson murder charge after a second fatal DUI.
Whether treatment is actually available
This is the part that matters most in practice and gets the least attention.
The statute authorizes treatment. It does not create capacity. Availability differs sharply between counties, and a residential place that exists on paper may have a waiting list measured in months.
So the question in any individual case is not only whether a treatment-mandated resolution is legally available, but whether a specific program can actually take the person, when, and on what terms. That is something to establish before a disposition is agreed, not after.
What this means if you are charged now
The date of the alleged offense matters. Conduct before December 18, 2024 is generally governed by the previous law.
Your record matters more than it did. Two prior theft convictions convert what would have been a misdemeanor into a potential felony. Prior convictions that seemed resolved years ago now carry consequences they did not carry before.
Clearing old convictions has become more valuable. A prior that has been reduced under Penal Code section 17(b) or dismissed under section 1203.4 sits differently. If you have old theft convictions on your record, dealing with them is now a more urgent proposition than it was in 2023.
Advice written before 2025 may be wrong. That includes a great deal of what is still published online, and it is worth checking the date on anything you read about California theft and drug charges, including this page.
Frequently Asked Questions
When did Proposition 36 take effect?
December 18, 2024, having passed on November 5, 2024 with roughly 68% of the vote. Conduct before that date is generally governed by the previous law, which is why the date of the alleged offense matters.
Is theft under $950 still a misdemeanor?
Usually, but no longer automatically. Proposition 36 lets prosecutors charge it as a felony where the person has two or more prior theft convictions. Without those priors it remains a misdemeanor.
What is a treatment-mandated felony?
A new category for certain repeat drug offenses. The person can be ordered into treatment instead of prison, and completing it can result in the charge being dismissed. Failing to complete it exposes him to up to three years.
Did Proposition 36 repeal Proposition 47?
No. It rolled back specific parts. Proposition 47's core reclassifications remain, including the $950 threshold itself and the shoplifting offense in Penal Code section 459.5.
Is treatment actually available?
That is the open question. Treatment capacity varies sharply between counties, and the Governor noted during the campaign that a number of California counties have no residential treatment facility at all. Whether a particular program can be accessed locally is a practical question worth asking early.
Hire Dan Harralson to resolve your legal difficulties.
The first conversation is free, and there is no obligation.

