Criminal Defense

Fresno Juvenile Defense Attorney

There is no jury in juvenile court, and the record does not automatically disappear at eighteen.

Overview of Juvenile Defense

In short

California juvenile cases proceed under Welfare and Institutions Code section 602 before a judge, with no jury, and the disposition is framed around rehabilitation. Since Proposition 57 a prosecutor cannot file directly in adult court; a transfer hearing is required, and since 2019 minors under 16 cannot be tried as adults at all.

Juvenile court uses different words for everything, and the vocabulary hides how much is at stake. A minor is not charged, he has a petition filed. He is not convicted; the petition is sustained. He is not sentenced; there is a disposition.

The language is genuinely rehabilitative in intent. It is also easy for a family to under-react to, and the consequences of a sustained petition can reach into adulthood.

The structure

A case under Welfare and Institutions Code section 602 runs through a detention hearing, a jurisdictional hearing, and a disposition.

There is no jury. A judge decides the facts. The standard remains proof beyond a reasonable doubt and the rules of evidence apply, but the decision-maker is a judge who hears these matters every day and has seen a great many versions of the same account.

Disposition options run from informal supervision through probation at home, to placement outside the home, to commitment, and for serious offenses, a transfer to adult court.

An attorney must be consulted before any questioning

This provision is not widely known and it matters enormously.

Welfare and Institutions Code section 625.6 requires that a minor aged 17 or under consult with counsel (in person, by telephone or by video) before a custodial interrogation and before any waiver of Miranda rights. The consultation cannot be waived. Not by the minor, and not by a parent.

Statements taken in breach of it are open to challenge. If your child has been questioned, the first thing worth establishing is whether that consultation happened.

Parents are not the client, and that is a difficult conversation

The attorney represents the minor. Confidentiality runs to the minor, and his interests are not always identical to his parents’.

That is often uncomfortable for families who are paying and who want to know everything. It is also what makes the representation worth having: a young person who cannot speak candidly to his attorney cannot be properly defended.

Transfer to adult court

Before Proposition 57, a prosecutor could file certain cases directly in adult court. That power is gone. A transfer hearing under section 707 is now required, at which the prosecution must persuade the court that the minor is not amenable to rehabilitation within the juvenile system.

The court weighs criminal sophistication, prior delinquent history, previous attempts at rehabilitation, and the circumstances of the alleged offense. Since 2019, minors under 16 cannot be transferred at all.

These hearings are contested with evidence (psychological evaluation, school records, family circumstances, treatment history), and they are among the most consequential proceedings in the system.

The record, and what happens to it

Juvenile records are confidential, but confidential is not the same as gone, and they do not seal themselves automatically in every case.

Section 786 provides for sealing on satisfactory completion of probation, and section 781 allows a petition to seal later. Some serious offenses are excluded. Where sealing is available it should be pursued deliberately, because an unsealed juvenile record can surface in military enlistment, professional licensing and certain employment screening years afterwards.

The best outcomes happen early

Informal supervision under section 654.2 and deferred entry of judgment under section 790 can resolve a matter without a sustained petition at all, usually through counselling, community service and school conditions.

Both are most readily available before positions harden. That is the practical argument for involving an attorney before the first hearing rather than after the first one has gone badly.

Frequently Asked Questions