Fresno Homicide Defense Attorney
The most serious charge California brings, and the one where the difference between degrees is measured in decades.
Overview of Homicide Defense
In short
California divides unlawful killing into first and second degree murder under Penal Code sections 187 and 189, and voluntary and involuntary manslaughter under section 192. Senate Bill 1437 narrowed the felony murder rule in 2019 so that a participant is generally liable only if he killed, intended to kill, or was a major participant acting with reckless indifference.
Dan Harralson has defended homicide cases in Fresno County and in federal court for 43 years, including first degree murder prosecutions. No client of his has been convicted of first degree murder.
Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome. Every case turns on its own facts.
The degrees, and why they decide everything
First degree murder (Penal Code section 189) covers a willful, deliberate and premeditated killing, a killing by certain specified means, and a killing during enumerated felonies. Twenty-five years to life.
Second degree murder: any other killing with malice. Fifteen years to life.
Voluntary manslaughter (section 192(a)): an intentional killing on a sudden quarrel or in the heat of passion, on provocation that would arouse passion in a reasonable person. Three, six or eleven years.
Involuntary manslaughter (section 192(b)): a killing through criminal negligence or during an unlawful act not amounting to a felony. Two, three or four years.
The facts rarely change between these. What changes is the characterisation of the defendant’s mental state, and the difference between the top and the bottom of that list is most of a life.
Premeditation is not time
Juries are instructed that premeditation requires a decision to kill made after weighing considerations, but that the period of reflection can be brief. Prosecutors use that instruction to convert a few seconds into deliberation.
The response is the evidence of what those seconds actually contained: the sequence of events, the position of the parties, what was said, what the physical evidence shows about distance and movement. This is where a first degree case frequently becomes a second degree case, and it is won with reconstruction and expert evidence rather than argument.
Heat of passion and imperfect self-defense
Two doctrines reduce murder to voluntary manslaughter.
Heat of passion applies where the defendant acted under the influence of intense emotion caused by legally adequate provocation, before a reasonable person would have cooled off.
Imperfect self-defense applies where the defendant actually believed he was in imminent danger and that deadly force was necessary, but that belief was unreasonable. The honest belief negates malice.
Where self-defense was both honest and reasonable, the killing is lawful and there is no crime at all.
Felony murder after SB 1437
For decades, anyone participating in certain felonies could be convicted of murder if someone died, regardless of intent. The driver who never entered the building faced the same charge as the person who fired.
Senate Bill 1437 changed that in 2019. Under Penal Code section 189(e), liability now generally requires that the person was the actual killer, aided the actual killer with the intent to kill, or was a major participant in the underlying felony who acted with reckless indifference to human life.
Penal Code section 1172.6 allows people convicted under the former rule to petition for resentencing. Those petitions are still being litigated, and for some long-serving prisoners they are the most significant development in California homicide law in a generation.
Vehicular cases and the Watson murder
A fatal DUI is not always charged as manslaughter. Where a driver has a prior DUI conviction and was given the standard advisement about the dangers of driving under the influence, the prosecution may charge second degree murder on an implied malice theory, the Watson doctrine.
The difference between vehicular manslaughter and second degree murder in that situation is roughly a decade, and it turns on evidence about knowledge and conscious disregard rather than on the collision itself.
What has to happen immediately
The prosecution’s investigation began at the scene, with the resources of a police department and a crime lab. Every day that passes before an independent defense investigation starts is a day of degraded evidence: footage overwritten, the scene altered, witness memory settling into whatever version has been repeated most.
In a case of this seriousness, that early work is not a formality. It is usually where the difference between the degrees is found.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between murder and manslaughter?
Malice. Murder under Penal Code section 187 requires malice aforethought: an intent to kill, or conscious disregard for human life. Manslaughter under section 192 is an unlawful killing without malice, either in the heat of passion on adequate provocation, or through criminal negligence.
What changed about the felony murder rule in California?
Senate Bill 1437, effective 2019, substantially narrowed it. A participant in a felony during which someone died can now generally only be convicted of murder if he was the actual killer, aided the killer with intent to kill, or was a major participant acting with reckless indifference to human life. Penal Code section 1172.6 allows people convicted under the old rule to petition for resentencing.
Is self-defense available on a homicide charge?
Yes. A killing in lawful self-defense or defense of another is not a crime at all. Where the belief in the need for deadly force was genuine but unreasonable (imperfect self-defense), the charge is reduced to voluntary manslaughter rather than murder.
Can a traffic collision be charged as murder?
It can. Where a driver has a prior DUI conviction and received the standard advisement about the dangers of drunk driving, a subsequent fatal DUI can be charged as second degree murder under the Watson doctrine, rather than as vehicular manslaughter.
What should happen first in a homicide case?
Independent investigation, immediately. Scene evidence, surveillance footage and witness recollection all degrade within days. The prosecution's investigation began at the scene; a defense that starts months later at the preliminary hearing is working from what is left.
