Fresno Domestic Violence Defense Attorney
The protective order is issued before the case is heard, and the consequences start before anyone has decided whether the allegation is true.
Overview of Domestic Violence
In short
California charges domestic violence mainly under Penal Code section 273.5, a wobbler that can be a felony or misdemeanor, or section 243(e)(1) for battery without visible injury. A conviction carries a mandatory 52-week batterer's program, a protective order, and a lifetime federal firearm ban. The alleged victim cannot drop the case.
A domestic violence arrest moves faster than almost any other charge. Police responding to a call in California are directed toward an arrest where they find probable cause, often within an hour of a dispute neither party had intended to escalate. A protective order follows at arraignment. The consequences begin while the facts are still entirely untested.
What is actually charged
Penal Code section 273.5 is the main charge: willfully inflicting corporal injury resulting in a “traumatic condition” on a spouse, former spouse, cohabitant, fiancé, dating partner, or the other parent of your child.
“Traumatic condition” is a lower threshold than the phrase suggests. Redness, a scratch, minor swelling will satisfy it. Section 273.5 is a wobbler: it can be filed as a misdemeanor or a felony, and as a felony it carries two, three or four years in state prison.
Penal Code section 243(e)(1) covers battery against the same category of people where there is no visible injury. It is a misdemeanor, and the difference between it and a felony 273.5 is sometimes one photograph taken at the scene in bad light.
The complaining witness cannot end it
This is the single most common misunderstanding. People frequently assume that if the other person tells the prosecutor they do not want to proceed, the case goes away.
It does not. The charging decision belongs to the District Attorney. Fresno County follows the standard California practice of pursuing these cases regardless of the complaining witness’s wishes, often building the case around the 911 recording, the body-worn camera footage, the responding officers’ observations and photographs taken that night.
A recantation becomes something the prosecution works around rather than something that ends the prosecution. It can also expose the person recanting to pressure they did not anticipate.
The protective order starts immediately
At arraignment the court will usually issue a criminal protective order. It can require you to stay away from your own home, surrender firearms, and limit or eliminate contact with your children pending the case.
Violating it is a separate crime under Penal Code section 166, including where the protected person initiated the contact. A text message answered out of ordinary decency becomes a new charge. This is where otherwise defensible cases are lost.
Consequences that outlast the sentence
Penal Code section 1203.097 makes certain terms mandatory on any domestic violence probation: at least 36 months of probation, a protective order, and completion of a 52-week batterer’s intervention program. That is a year of weekly attendance, at the defendant’s expense.
Firearms. A conviction, even a misdemeanor, triggers a lifetime federal prohibition on possessing firearms or ammunition under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(9). For anyone in law enforcement, the military, or private security, that is usually the end of the career.
Immigration. A crime of domestic violence is a ground of removability. Non-citizens have had permanent residence undone by a misdemeanor plea entered to resolve a case quickly.
Family law. A finding of domestic violence creates a rebuttable presumption against awarding custody under Family Code section 3044.
Where the defense usually lies
Many of these cases are mutual altercations in which one person called first. Self-defense is a real defense and it is frequently the truth of the incident. So is an injury that was accidental, or that predated the argument, or that was inflicted during a struggle over a phone.
The practical work is early: preserving the 911 audio and body-worn camera footage before it cycles off, identifying witnesses, documenting your own injuries that night rather than weeks later, and getting a defense view in front of the prosecutor before charging decisions harden.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the alleged victim drop the charges?
No. The decision belongs to the District Attorney, not the complaining witness. Fresno County, like most California jurisdictions, follows a policy of pursuing these cases even where the alleged victim recants or declines to cooperate.
What is the difference between PC 273.5 and PC 243(e)(1)?
Section 273.5 requires a "traumatic condition": a visible injury, however minor, including redness or swelling. Section 243(e)(1) covers offensive touching of a partner without visible injury and is a misdemeanor. The distinction often turns on a single photograph taken at the scene.
Will I lose my right to own a firearm?
Yes, and this catches people out. Even a misdemeanor domestic violence conviction triggers a lifetime federal ban under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(9). California adds its own ten-year prohibition for many misdemeanors. For anyone in law enforcement, the military or private security, this is frequently the career consequence.
What happens at the first hearing?
A criminal protective order is usually issued at arraignment, before any evidence has been tested. It can bar you from your own home and limit contact with your children. Violating it is a separate crime even if the other person initiated the contact.
Is a domestic violence conviction a deportable offense?
It can be. A crime of domestic violence is a ground of removability under federal immigration law, and that consequence can follow a misdemeanor plea that seemed minor at the time. Anyone who is not a US citizen needs that assessed before entering any plea.
