Criminal Defense

Fresno Theft Crimes Defense Attorney

Proposition 36 undid part of what Proposition 47 had done. Theft under $950 is no longer automatically a misdemeanor.

Overview of Theft Crimes

In short

Since Proposition 36 took effect on December 18, 2024, California prosecutors can charge theft under $950 as a felony if the person has two or more prior theft convictions. Below that threshold and without those priors it remains a misdemeanor. Grand theft over $950 has always been a wobbler.

California’s approach to theft has moved twice in a decade, and a great deal of the advice circulating about it is now out of date.

What Proposition 47 did, and what Proposition 36 undid

Proposition 47, in 2014, made theft of property worth $950 or less a misdemeanor in nearly all cases, and created the shoplifting offense in Penal Code section 459.5 so that walking into a shop intending to steal was no longer charged as felony burglary.

Proposition 36 passed on November 5, 2024 with roughly 68% of the vote and took effect on December 18, 2024. For theft it changed two things:

  • a person with two or more prior theft convictions can now be charged with a felony for theft under $950; and
  • organized retail theft involving three or more people acting together carries increased penalties.

So the clean “under $950 is a misdemeanor” rule no longer holds for anyone with a theft history. That is the single most important thing to know about a current California theft charge, and it is why advice from before 2025 should be treated with caution.

The charges

Petty theft: Penal Code sections 484 and 490.2. Property worth $950 or less. A misdemeanor unless the Proposition 36 prior-conviction exception applies.

Shoplifting: section 459.5. Entering a commercial establishment during business hours intending to steal $950 or less. A misdemeanor. Entering outside business hours, or with intent to take more than $950, remains burglary.

Grand theft: section 487. Value above $950, or property taken directly from the person, or certain categories such as firearms and vehicles. A wobbler, chargeable as a misdemeanor or a felony.

Burglary: section 459. Entering a structure with intent to commit theft or any felony. Residential burglary is a serious felony and a strike.

Value is an argument, not a fact

The $950 threshold decides how a case is charged, and value is measured by fair market value at the time of the taking, not the retail price on the label.

Loss prevention reports routinely use retail price. For used goods, for clearance stock, for items that were discounted, the difference can be substantial, and it is sometimes the whole difference between a misdemeanor and a felony. It is worth contesting rather than conceding.

Intent is the other real issue

Every theft charge requires an intent to permanently deprive, formed at the right moment. That is often where the genuine defense lies: a distracted parent with an item under the pushchair, goods placed in a bag while the person intended to pay, a genuine belief of ownership or permission, or an item taken by mistake.

These are not technicalities. They are the ordinary facts of a large share of the retail cases filed in Fresno County every month, and they are frequently provable through the store’s own camera footage, which has to be requested before it is overwritten.

What it costs afterwards

Theft convictions are treated by employers as crimes of dishonesty, and they disqualify people from work in retail, banking, healthcare and anything requiring a professional license or a bond. For many clients that consequence dwarfs the sentence.

This is why a reduction under Penal Code section 17(b), a dismissal under section 1203.4, or a disposition that avoids a theft conviction altogether is frequently the real objective, rather than simply minimizing custody.

Frequently Asked Questions