Criminal Defense

Fresno Assault and Battery Defense Attorney

Assault and battery are different offenses, and the one you are charged with usually matters more than the facts suggest.

Overview of Assault & Battery

In short

In California assault under Penal Code section 240 is an attempt to apply force; battery under section 242 is the actual touching. Both are misdemeanors. Assault with a deadly weapon under section 245(a) is a wobbler, a felony version of which is a strike. Self-defense is a complete defense.

Most assault and battery charges in Fresno County come out of a fight that both people were part of. One of them called the police, or one of them was still standing when officers arrived, and the roles of defendant and victim were assigned in the first few minutes.

That is the situation these cases usually have to be unpicked from.

Two different offenses

Assault (Penal Code section 240) is an unlawful attempt, with the present ability, to commit a violent injury on someone. No contact is required. A swing that misses is assault.

Battery (section 242) is the willful and unlawful use of force or violence on another person. No injury is required. An offensive touching is enough.

Both are misdemeanors in their basic form, carrying up to six months (assault) or six months (battery) in county jail, with battery causing serious bodily injury under section 243(d) chargeable as a felony.

Where it becomes serious

Penal Code section 245(a)(1) (assault with a deadly weapon, or by means of force likely to produce great bodily injury) is the charge that changes a case.

“Deadly weapon” is broader than people expect. A bottle, a boot, a length of pipe, a vehicle and in some cases a dog have all qualified, depending on how they were used. And the section reaches force likely to cause great bodily injury with no weapon at all, which can mean a sustained beating with fists.

It is a wobbler. As a felony it is a serious felony under section 1192.7(c), which makes it a strike: it doubles the sentence on any future felony and counts toward a third-strike exposure for the rest of your life.

Reducing a section 245 charge to a misdemeanor under Penal Code section 17(b) is often worth more to a client over a lifetime than the difference in custody.

The enhancement that outweighs the charge

Penal Code section 12022.7 adds three consecutive years for personally inflicting great bodily injury. Other enhancements apply for firearm use.

These are charged separately from the offense and they are frequently where the real exposure sits. A case can be worth fighting primarily to defeat the enhancement, even where the underlying battery is not seriously in dispute.

Self-defense

California permits the use of reasonable force to defend yourself or someone else against what you reasonably believe is an imminent threat, and there is no duty to retreat. You may stand your ground and, if reasonably necessary, pursue an assailant until the danger has passed.

The force has to be proportionate, and the right to use it ends when the threat does. But in a mutual fight the question of who was defending himself is genuinely open, and it is answered by evidence rather than by who the officers spoke to first: the 911 audio, body-worn camera footage, bar or business cameras, independent witnesses, and the injuries on both people documented the same night.

That evidence has a short life. Business camera systems commonly overwrite within days. Getting it before it is gone is most of what an early defense consists of.

Frequently Asked Questions