Guide

The Ten-Day DMV Deadline After a DUI Arrest

A DUI arrest starts two separate cases. The DMV one gives you ten days to request a hearing, and most people miss it. What to do.

By Daniel L. Harralson, California bar no. 109322 ·

In short

A California DUI arrest starts two separate proceedings: a criminal case and a DMV action to suspend your license. You have ten days from service of the suspension order to request a DMV hearing under Vehicle Code section 13558. Miss it and the suspension takes effect automatically, whatever the criminal court later decides.

Almost everyone arrested for DUI in California understands that they have a court date. Far fewer understand that a second, entirely separate case started the same night, and that its deadline is ten days.

Two cases, not one

The criminal case is brought by the District Attorney in the Superior Court, under Vehicle Code section 23152. It can result in fines, probation, programs, and custody.

The administrative case is run by the DMV under Vehicle Code section 13353.2. It decides one thing: whether your license is suspended. It does not care about the criminal court’s view and it does not wait for it.

They have different decision-makers, different rules of evidence and different standards of proof. Winning one does not win the other. People are acquitted in court and suspended by the DMV, and the reverse happens too.

The ten days

When you were arrested, the officer almost certainly took your license and handed you a pink piece of paper. That paper is a temporary license, and it is also the notice of suspension.

From the date it was served, you have ten days to request a hearing under Vehicle Code section 13558. Weekends count. Holidays count.

Miss the window and the suspension takes effect automatically, normally thirty days after the notice. There is no appeal as of right, and a later dismissal of the criminal case will not reverse it.

This is the most commonly missed deadline in California criminal practice, and it is missed for an understandable reason: in the days after an arrest, people are focused on the court date printed on the citation, which is usually weeks away.

Requesting the hearing usually keeps you driving

A timely request does two things.

It normally stays the suspension until the hearing is decided, so you keep driving in the meantime, which for most people is the difference between keeping a job and losing one.

And it creates a proceeding at which the officer can be subpoenaed and questioned under oath, months before the criminal trial. What is said there is on the record, and it is frequently useful in the criminal case regardless of how the DMV hearing itself comes out.

Even where the administrative outcome looks unlikely, those two benefits are usually worth the request on their own.

What the hearing is actually about

The DMV’s scope is narrow. Broadly:

  • did the officer have reasonable cause to believe you were driving under the influence;
  • were you lawfully arrested;
  • were you driving with a BAC of 0.08% or more.

That narrowness cuts both ways. Much of what matters in the criminal case is irrelevant here. But the issues that are in scope (the basis for the stop, the conduct of the arrest, the calibration and administration of the breath test, the timing of the blood draw and the chain of custody) are genuinely contestable, and they are contested on the documents and the officer’s testimony.

If you refused the test

A refusal carries its own suspension (a year for a first refusal under Vehicle Code section 13353), and it can be used as evidence of consciousness of guilt in the criminal case.

The same ten-day rule applies, and whether a refusal actually occurred as a matter of law is more often arguable than people assume.

What to do today

If you were arrested in the last ten days, request the hearing. It is the one step that cannot be taken later, and taking it costs you nothing except the phone call.

If the ten days have already passed, say so when you call rather than assuming nothing can be done; there are limited circumstances in which the position can still be addressed, and they are worth checking quickly rather than eventually.

Frequently Asked Questions

Hire Dan Harralson to resolve your legal difficulties.

The first conversation is free, and there is no obligation.